19 Etsy Alternatives for Artisans and Shoppers

Last updated on September 11, 2024

Discover alternatives to Etsy and their pros and cons. Read on!

Have you ever found yourself scrolling through Etsy, admiring all of the beautiful home decor but feeling discouraged by the prices? I know firsthand how expensive it can be to create a stunning decor.

But fear not, my fellow budget-conscious decorators! There are plenty of alternative options out there that won’t break the bank.

In this article, I’ll share 20 Etsy alternatives with their advantages and disadvantages so you can find affordable and unique pieces to elevate your space without sacrificing style.

Amazon Handmade

When it comes to online marketplaces for handmade goods, Amazon Handmade is a popular choice. The platform offers a wide range of products from artisans and makers around the world.

One advantage of using Amazon Handmade is its large customer base, which can increase visibility and sales for sellers.

However, one disadvantage is that there are strict guidelines for what can be sold on the platform. Products must be made entirely by hand or with hand tools, and mass-produced items are not allowed. There is a monthly fee to sell on Amazon Handmade.

Despite these limitations, many sellers have found success on the platform due to its vast reach and reputation as a trusted marketplace. It’s worth considering as an alternative option when looking beyond Etsy for selling handmade goods online.

EBay

When it comes to online marketplaces, eBay is a well-known name. It’s been around since 1995 and has over 185 million active buyers worldwide.

While eBay isn’t specifically geared towards handmade or vintage items like Etsy, it does offer a wide range of products at competitive prices.

One advantage of using eBay as an alternative to Etsy is the sheer volume of traffic that the site receives. With so many users actively buying and selling on the platform, there’s potential for your products to reach a larger audience than they might on other sites.

However, one disadvantage is that because there are so many sellers on eBay offering similar items, it can be challenging to stand out from the crowd without investing in advertising or promotions.

While some buyers may appreciate being able to bid on items through auctions rather than paying fixed prices like they would with Etsy listings – others may find this process frustrating or time-consuming.

Overall though if you’re looking for an alternative marketplace with high visibility and plenty of potential customers – then considering selling your wares via ebay could be worth exploring further!

Bonanza

One of the Etsy alternatives that has been gaining popularity in recent years is Bonanza. This online marketplace boasts over 50,000 sellers and millions of products available for purchase.

One advantage of using Bonanza is its user-friendly interface, making it easy to navigate and find what you’re looking for.

Another advantage is the lower fees compared to Etsy, with a flat rate fee per sale rather than a percentage-based fee. However, one disadvantage could be the smaller customer base compared to larger marketplaces like Amazon or eBay.

If you’re looking for an alternative platform with lower fees and a simpler layout than Etsy but still offers plenty of options from various sellers around the world – then Bonanza may be worth checking out!

Zibbet

Zibbet is an online marketplace that offers a platform for independent artists, designers, and crafters to sell their handmade goods. It was founded in 2009 and has since grown into a community of over 50,000 sellers from around the world.

One advantage of Zibbet is its user-friendly interface that allows sellers to easily manage their inventory and sales. The platform also offers various marketing tools such as social media integration and email campaigns to help promote products.

However, one disadvantage of Zibbet is its limited customer base compared to larger marketplaces like Etsy or Amazon Handmade. This can make it challenging for new sellers on the platform to gain visibility and attract customers.

Zibbet may be a good alternative option for those looking for a smaller community feel with easy-to-use features but may not be ideal if you are looking for maximum exposure or have high-volume sales goals.

ArtFire

ArtFire is an online marketplace that offers a wide range of handmade and vintage items. It was founded in 2008 and has since grown to become a popular alternative to Etsy.

One advantage of ArtFire is its lower fees compared to Etsy, which can be beneficial for sellers looking to save money on listing their products. ArtFire offers unlimited listings for free accounts, making it easier for small businesses or individuals with limited budgets to sell their products.

However, one disadvantage of ArtFire is its smaller user base compared to Etsy’s massive community. This means that there may be less traffic and potential customers visiting the site regularly.

Another downside is the lack of customization options available when creating your shop on Artfire.

Despite these drawbacks, many sellers have found success on Artfire by utilizing its unique features such as customizable coupons and discounts offered through social media promotions. If you’re looking for an affordable alternative platform with some unique selling tools at your disposal then it’s worth considering giving this marketplace a try!

Big Cartel

Big Cartel is a popular choice among artists and creatives who want an easy-to-use platform to sell their products without breaking the bank.

The site offers a free plan that allows users to list up to five products with limited features and paid plans starting at $9.99 per month with more advanced features like inventory tracking and custom domain names.

One advantage of using Big Cartel over Etsy or other platforms is its simplicity – it’s straightforward and easy-to-use interface makes setting up shop quick and painless even for those new in e-commerce business. Unlike some competitors which take commission on sales made through their sites, Big cartel doesn’t charge any transaction fees on sales made through its site.

However, one disadvantage of using this platform could be its limited functionality compared with larger marketplaces like Amazon Handmade or eBay. It also lacks some key features such as built-in shipping labels printing which can make fulfilling orders time-consuming if you have many orders coming in daily.

Overall though, if you’re looking for an affordable way start selling your handmade goods online without too much hassle then big cartel might just be what you need!

Storenvy

This online marketplace offers a wide range of products from independent sellers, including handmade items and vintage finds.

One advantage of using Storenvy is the ability to discover new and emerging artists who may not have a presence on larger platforms like Etsy. Many sellers offer lower prices on their products compared to other marketplaces.

However, one disadvantage of using Storenvy is that there are fewer options available compared to larger marketplaces like Amazon or eBay. It can also be more difficult to find specific items due to the smaller selection.

If you’re looking for unique home decor at an affordable price point while supporting independent artists and makers, then exploring what’s available on Storenvy could be worth your time.

Society6

Society6 is an online marketplace that offers a wide range of unique and creative home decor items. The platform features designs from independent artists around the world, making it a great place to find one-of-a-kind pieces for your home.

Society6’s product offerings include wall art, furniture, bedding, pillows and more.

One advantage of shopping on Society6 is the variety of styles available. With so many different artists contributing to the site’s inventory, you’re sure to find something that fits your personal taste and aesthetic preferences.

However, one potential disadvantage is that prices can be higher than other budget-friendly alternatives like Etsy or thrift stores. Since each item on Society6 is made-to-order by individual artists rather than mass-produced in bulk quantities like some larger retailers offer; shipping times may vary depending on where you live or how busy their production schedule happens to be at any given time.

Overall though if you’re looking for unique decor items with artistic flair then checking out what’s available through this platform could definitely be worth considering!

Redbubble

When it comes to finding unique and affordable home decor, Redbubble is a great alternative to Etsy. This online marketplace offers a wide range of products designed by independent artists from around the world.

From wall art and throw pillows to shower curtains and duvet covers, you can find just about anything on Redbubble.

One advantage of shopping on Redbubble is the variety of designs available. With thousands of artists contributing their work, there’s something for every taste and style preference.

Many items are customizable so you can add your own personal touch.

However, one disadvantage is that some items may be more expensive than similar products found on Etsy or other marketplaces due to shipping costs or artist fees. It’s important to compare prices before making a purchase.

If you’re looking for unique home decor options with an artistic flair at reasonable prices then checking out what Redbubble has in store might be worth your while!

CafePress

CafePress is an online marketplace that allows users to create and sell their own designs on a variety of products, including home decor items. The advantage of using CafePress is the ability to customize your decor with unique designs created by independent artists.

CafePress offers a wide range of products such as throw pillows, wall art, and blankets at affordable prices.

However, one disadvantage of using CafePress for home decor is that the quality may not always be consistent across all products. Some customers have reported issues with print quality or durability over time.

Another potential downside is limited options for customization beyond choosing from existing designs or uploading your own artwork.

If you’re looking for affordable and customizable home decor options featuring unique designs from independent artists then CafePress could be worth exploring further – make sure to read reviews carefully before making any purchases!

Zazzle

When it comes to finding unique and affordable home decor, Zazzle is a great alternative to Etsy. This online marketplace offers a wide range of customizable products, from wall art and throw pillows to curtains and table runners.

One advantage of using Zazzle is the ability to personalize your decor with your own photos or designs. You can also choose from thousands of pre-made designs created by independent artists around the world.

However, one disadvantage is that some items on Zazzle may be more expensive than similar products on Etsy due to the customization options available. Shipping times may vary depending on where you are located in relation to the seller’s location.

If you’re looking for personalized home decor options beyond what Etsy has available or want something truly unique for your space, give Zazzle a try!

Folksy

Folksy is a UK-based online marketplace that focuses on handmade and vintage items. It has a smaller community compared to Etsy, but it offers unique products from independent sellers.

One of the advantages of Folksy is its strict guidelines for sellers, ensuring that all items sold are genuinely handmade or vintage. This gives buyers peace of mind knowing they are purchasing authentic products.

However, one disadvantage is the limited international reach as it primarily caters to UK customers only. Some users have reported difficulty navigating the website and finding specific items due to its less user-friendly interface.

Despite these drawbacks, Folksy remains an excellent alternative for those looking for high-quality handmade or vintage goods within the UK market.

Shopify

Shopify is a popular e-commerce platform that allows individuals and businesses to create their own online stores. While it may not be as well-known for handmade or vintage items like Etsy, Shopify offers several advantages for those looking to sell their products online.

One of the biggest advantages is the ability to fully customize your store’s design and layout, giving you complete control over your brand image. Shopify offers powerful tools for managing inventory, processing payments, and shipping orders quickly and efficiently.

However, one disadvantage of using Shopify is that it can be more expensive than other platforms like Etsy due to monthly fees and transaction fees on each sale made through the site. Overall though if you’re looking for a professional-looking storefront with robust features then Shopify could be an excellent alternative option compared with Etsy or other marketplaces out there!

ICraft

One of the lesser-known alternatives to Etsy is iCraft. This online marketplace offers a wide range of handmade and vintage items, as well as supplies for crafting enthusiasts.

One advantage of iCraft is that it has a smaller seller base than Etsy, which means less competition for sellers and potentially more visibility for their products.

However, one disadvantage is that the site’s user interface can be difficult to navigate at times. While there are no listing fees on iCraft, they do take a 7% commission on sales made through their platform.

Despite these drawbacks, many sellers have found success on iCraft by utilizing its unique features such as customizable storefronts and social media integration. It may be worth considering this alternative marketplace if you’re looking to expand your reach beyond Etsy.

Madeit

Madeit is an Australian-based online marketplace that offers a platform for independent artists and designers to sell their handmade products. The site has over 10,000 sellers offering unique items such as jewelry, homewares, clothing, and art.

One of the advantages of Madeit is its focus on supporting local businesses and promoting sustainable practices by encouraging the use of eco-friendly materials.

However, one disadvantage could be limited international shipping options compared to other marketplaces like Etsy. While Madeit does offer a wide range of products from various categories such as fashion accessories or home decor items; it may not have the same level of variety in terms of product selection when compared with larger platforms like Amazon Handmade or eBay.

Overall though if you’re looking for something truly unique that supports small business owners within Australia then MadeIt might just be what you need!

DaWanda

DaWanda is a European-based online marketplace that specializes in handmade goods and vintage items. It has a strong presence in Germany but also operates in other countries across Europe.

One advantage of using DaWanda over Etsy is its focus on European sellers, which can provide access to unique products not found elsewhere. The site offers lower fees for sellers compared to Etsy’s commission structure.

However, one disadvantage of using DaWanda may be its limited reach outside of Europe. This could make it difficult for buyers looking for specific items or wanting more variety from different regions around the world.

If you’re based in Europe or looking specifically for handmade goods from this region then DaWanda could be an excellent alternative to consider when searching for your next home decor piece on a budget!

Aftcra

One of the Etsy alternatives that is gaining popularity among home decorators and craft enthusiasts is Aftcra. This online marketplace was launched in 2013 with a mission to support American artisans and small businesses by providing them with a platform to sell their handmade goods.

One advantage of using Aftcra over Etsy is its focus on promoting American-made products. This means that buyers can feel good about supporting local businesses while also finding unique decor items for their homes.

However, one disadvantage of Aftcra compared to Etsy is its smaller user base. Since it’s still relatively new, there may be fewer options available for buyers looking for specific types of decor or styles.

If you’re interested in supporting American artisans and want an alternative to Etsy, then checking out what’s available on Aftcra could be worth your time.

BigCommerce

When it comes to e-commerce platforms, BigCommerce is a popular choice for small businesses and entrepreneurs. It offers a range of features such as customizable templates, secure payment gateways, and inventory management tools.

One advantage of using BigCommerce is its scalability – it can accommodate businesses of all sizes and can handle high traffic volumes without compromising on performance.

However, one disadvantage is that the pricing plans may be too expensive for some small business owners who are just starting out. While there are many customization options available with BigCommerce’s templates, they may require some technical knowledge to fully utilize them.

Overall though, if you’re looking for an e-commerce platform that offers flexibility in terms of design and functionality while also being scalable enough to grow with your business needs over time then BigCommerce could be worth considering as an alternative to Etsy or other online marketplaces.

NuMONDAY

NuMONDAY is a UK-based online marketplace that offers handmade and vintage items. It was founded in 2016 by two sisters who wanted to create a platform for independent sellers to showcase their unique creations.

One of the advantages of NuMONDAY is its focus on supporting small businesses, which means you can find one-of-a-kind items that are not available elsewhere. NuMONDAY has lower fees compared to other marketplaces like Etsy, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious shoppers.

However, one disadvantage of NuMONDAY is its limited reach outside the UK market. This may make it difficult for international buyers or sellers looking to expand their customer base beyond the UK borders.

Another potential downside is that since it’s still relatively new compared to established platforms like Etsy or Amazon Handmade, there may be fewer buyers and less traffic overall.

Overall though, if you’re based in the UK and looking for unique handmade or vintage finds while supporting small businesses at affordable prices with low fees – then NuMONDAY could be worth checking out!

Recap