Concrete Steven Universe: In-depth Character Analysis and Interpretation

Last updated on March 17, 2024

Explore the concrete attributes of Steven Universe because each characteristic holds a significant influence on the overall narrative arc of the popular show.

Key takeaways:

  • Concrete’s depiction in Steven Universe sparked controversy and criticism.
  • Fans raised concerns about racial stereotypes in Concrete’s design.
  • The fan response prompted wider conversations on diversity and representation.
  • The creators of Steven Universe issued an apology and implemented measures to promote inclusivity.
  • Representation and sensitivity in animation are crucial for diverse storytelling.

Controversy Surrounding Concrete

controversy surrounding concrete

The reveal of Concrete sparked a heated debate across “Steven Universe” fans and the broader online community. Concrete’s depiction was criticized for perpetuating racial stereotypes, primarily because of the character’s description in the “Steven Universe” art book, which included traits that were considered insensitive and offensive.

Specifically, people took issue with the character’s dark skin, exaggerated lips, and the implication that she could not read. These characteristics evoked a long history of racist minstrelsy and blackface, where such features were commonly used to belittle and dehumanize people of African descent.

The uproar was not just about the character alone but touched on larger themes of racial representation in media, and the responsibilities of content creators to be inclusive and avoid harmful clichés. This particular case became a catalyst for discussions on diversity within the “Steven Universe” community and the animation industry as a whole.

Description of Concrete’s First Appearance

description of concretes first appearance

Concrete made her first and only appearance in the “Steven Universe: Art & Origins” book released in 2017. Within the book’s pages, she’s featured among a collection of artwork depicting Gem character concepts not used in the show.

Concrete’s sketch was accompanied by handwritten notes that describe her characteristics. These include her inability to read and her having the ‘best intentions’ despite being ‘clumsy’.

The simple, grayscale drawing depicts a Gem with a thick build and tightly coiled hair, her eyes wide and lips full. This unique character exists as an exploration of the diverse creativity inherent in the design process of the series, providing a glimpse into the vast realm of possibilities that the show’s creators were considering.

Character Attributes of Concrete

In the “Steven Universe” artwork, Concrete boasts unique features that set her apart from other Gems. She is depicted with a gray, rough-textured skin reminiscent of her namesake, and patchy, white marks resembling concrete’s irregularities. Her hair is designed with bold, geometric shapes, further reinforcing her stony motif.

Unlike her Gem counterparts, Concrete is illustrated without a gemstone – a creative choice that stirred considerable discussion among fans. Notably, her character profile suggested she had difficulty reading, a detail that sparked controversy largely due to its perceived implications.

While her physical attributes aligned with the show’s diverse representation of Gems, it was the combination of these attributes and her description that ignited the larger conversation regarding representation and sensitivity.

Examination of Racial Stereotypes in Concrete’s Design

Upon closer inspection, Concrete’s concept art raised concerns due to characteristics that have historically been utilized to propagate racial stereotypes. Key points of critique include:

  • Illustration Features: Concrete is depicted with dark, gray skin and full, exaggerated lips. Such depictions echo minstrelsy’s visual tropes, which have a painful legacy of demeaning African Americans.
  • Character Traits: The character description mentioned an inability to read while possessing a desire to be “more cultured,” implying a lack of intelligence. This unfairly aligns with long-standing prejudices against the educational attainment of Black individuals.
  • Contextual Contrast: The design stands in contrast to “Steven Universe’s” usual celebration of diversity and inclusivity, highlighting why the character stirred discomfort among fans and advocates for representation.
  • Absent Voice: Lacking her own voice, Concrete could not communicate or dispel misconceptions, unlike other well-rounded characters in the series, which often use their voices to challenge stereotypes and grow.

Understanding these concerns is vital to recognizing why Concrete’s design was problematic and how it inadvertently aligned with antiquated and hurtful racial caricatures.

The Fan Response to Concrete

The reveal of Concrete prompted immediate and passionate discussions within the “Steven Universe” community. Fans took to social media platforms to voice concerns, noting that the sketch played into racial stereotypes, particularly due to its description mentioning Concrete’s inability to read.

– Fans noted that the combination of dark skin, big lips, and an apparent lack of intellectual ability, were reminiscent of historic racist caricatures.

– Some dedicated viewers created their own redesigns, offering alternative interpretations that did not invoke the same stereotypes.

– Fan discussions extended beyond Concrete, prompting wider conversations on diversity and representation in animated shows.

– The community’s response highlighted the importance of sensitivity in character design, especially in a series celebrated for its inclusivity and progressive themes.

– The controversy served to galvanize the fandom, leading to increased advocacy for responsible media representation and creator accountability.

By actively engaging with the issue, fans of “Steven Universe” demonstrated their commitment to the show’s underlying values of respect and acceptance.

The “Steven Universe” Creators’ Apology

Following the unintended offense, the creators of “Steven Universe” responded to the backlash concerning Concrete’s concept art. They issued a heartfelt apology acknowledging the insensitive undertones in the character’s depiction.

Key takeaways from their statement highlight important lessons:

  • Acknowledgment of Mistake: The team admitted that the character perpetuated racial stereotypes, which was never their intention.
  • Assurance of Responsibility: They took full responsibility for the oversight, without shifting blame.
  • Commitment to Action: The creators assured that steps would be taken to prevent similar issues in the future, showcasing a commitment to inclusivity and cultural sensitivity in their storytelling.
  • Open Dialogue: They welcomed constructive conversations with the fan community, demonstrating a willingness to learn and grow from the experience.

Impact On Future “Steven Universe” Content

Following the Concrete incident, the team behind “Steven Universe” took significant steps to ensure more respectful and diverse representation in their future content. Here are some of the measures implemented:

  • Enhanced Diversity Training: Writers and animators underwent sensitivity training to better understand cultural issues.
  • Inclusive Writing Rooms: The show increased efforts to include diverse voices in its storytelling process.
  • Character Design Review: A system was created to review new characters’ designs for potentially harmful stereotypes before they’re finalized.
  • Ongoing Dialogue with Fans: The creators maintained an open line of communication with fans, incorporating their feedback into the show’s development.
  • Storytelling Conscious of Impact: Future episodes placed a greater emphasis on the cultural significance of characters and storylines.

Representation and Sensitivity in Animation

Animation today is more than just entertainment; it’s a powerful medium for storytelling and representation. Here are key points that stress its importance:

  • Diverse Characters: Introducing a variety of characters from different backgrounds and identities offers audiences the chance to see themselves and others reflected in the stories they watch.
  • Cultural Authenticity: Animators and writers are urged to research and respect the cultures they depict. This ensures details are accurately and sensitively portrayed.
  • Avoiding Stereotypes: Steering clear of clichés and stereotypes prevents the reinforcement of harmful prejudices and promotes a more nuanced understanding of various groups.
  • Positive Role Models: Through thoughtful character development, animation can provide viewers with role models that inspire and teach valuable life lessons.
  • Inclusivity in Production: Including voices from a range of backgrounds in the writing room and production process leads to richer storytelling and authentic representation.
  • Dialogue with Fans: Openness to fan feedback helps creators understand different perspectives and improve the inclusivity and sensitivity of their work.
  • Educational Value: Animation can be a tool for educating viewers on social issues and fostering empathy, broadening their worldview from their living room.

By keeping these points in mind, animators and writers can create content that truly resonates with and respects the diversity of their audience.

Fan Initiatives for Positive Change Post-Concrete

In the wake of the Concrete incident, the “Steven Universe” fan community galvanized to foster positive change. They initiated dialogue about diversity and representation in media through forums and social media, leveraging the show’s themes of inclusion and love.

Fans created educational resources highlighting the importance of respectful character portrayals across all forms of entertainment. Additionally, they advocated for more involvement of people of color in creative processes to ensure authenticity and sensitivity.

The concerted effort also involved crowdfunding campaigns supporting artists from underrepresented groups, aiming to amplify their voices in the animation industry. These fan-led endeavors reinforced the notion that audiences play a pivotal role in shaping the media landscape towards inclusivity and equity.


Liked this article? Here's what you can read next: